External audit of Farm Radio International’s financial, accounting, and administrative management At Farm Radio International

1. INTRODUCTION

Farm Radio International (FRI) is a Canadian NGO registered in Nigeria as an INGO. Farm Radio International Headquarters is based in Ottawa, Canada, and it supports African broadcasters in strengthening small-scale farmers and rural communities’ capacity to tackle poverty and food insecurity through radio coupled with information and communication technology (ICT).

FRI’s work focuses on three areas:

• Broadcaster resources and training: We produce scripts, information packs, a weekly e-newsletter shared with thousands of African radio broadcasters, and we host an online community called Barza wire. We also offer skill training meant to support radio broadcasters in producing programs that will better serve their listeners.
• Radio Innovation: Farm Radio combined newer technology with radio to become an interactive communication tool by using the ULIZA suite of services.
• Impact programming: We collaborate with key research and development partners by helping them to use radio efficiently in their efforts to share knowledge and change behavior, and thus contribute to improve livelihoods at scale.

Farm Radio International works in direct partnership with more than 1,000 radio partners in 39 African countries, and it has offices in Nigeria, Ghana, Tanzania, Ethiopia, Uganda, Mali, Burkina Faso, Intern, and Senegal.

1. OVERALL OBJECTIVE OF THE AUDIT

The audit is intended to help auditors express a professional view on the financial and administrative situation with respect to the applicable regulations of FRI’s operation in Nigeria and the activities undertaken over the relevant period.

The audit will be performed according to acknowledged auditing principles and include all tests and controls deemed necessary for the occasion.

The auditor is responsible for providing an opinion on the financial statements based on international audit standards (ISA: International Standards on Auditing), published by the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC), and the regulations as applied to NGOs in Nigeria. Pursuant to these auditing standards, the auditor will ask Farm Radio International to submit a representation letter holding the management liable to produce the financial statement and maintain an appropriate internal control system.

1. SPECIFIC OBJECTIVE

The specific objectives of the audit include:

1. Having the auditor express his or her opinion on the financial report to ensure the person provide an accurate and faithful picture of the revenues and expenses of projects;
2. Evaluating the internal control procedures (purchases, reception, and storage of purchased goods, contracting with a third party, …) of projects through an evaluation of the internal control risks and the substantive deficiencies of this control.
3. Checking the compliance with the applicable laws and regulations to ensure that the recipient of the funds satisfactorily complied with the terms of the contract between the parties.
4. The representation letter the auditor must receive from the NGO’s senior managers, and where they attest to the best of their knowledge that the financial report covers all transactions made and that it is accurate and complete in all respects.
5. Making the inventory of the material and the equipment of projects.
6. Ensuring that the NGO staff enjoyed their rights.
7. Providing a complete report on the fiscal and social situation of Farm Radio International in Nigeria, with suggested solutions in case of non-compliance.
8. SCOPE OF THE MISSION

As mentioned above, projects will be audited in compliance with the International Standards of Auditing (ISA) published by IFAC, and it will consist of auditing tests and procedures, as well as controls the auditor will deem necessary under the circumstances.

The auditor will ensure, among other things, that:

• All resources available to the projects were used in accordance with the provisions of the applicable funding agreements, with due regard to economy and efficiency, and only for the purposes for which there were provided in reference to the funding agreement.
• Procurement of funded goods and services were done through contracts awarded or in accordance with FRI procurement procedures and that they were properly recorded in the account books of the projects.
• Approval is received from authorized persons at the various stages of the procurement procedure.
• There is compliance with the procurement methods approved in the procurement manual.
• All necessary records, accounts, and entries were maintained for various project transactions (including expenditures covered by expense reports or special accounts). The books of account and the reports submitted to funders should clearly match.
• The designated account is managed in consideration of the provisions of the funding agreements.
• The overall financial performance of the projects is satisfactory, when comparing the completion of the program activities against the performance indicators as described in the project documents and noting any shortcomings and delays as well as the reasons for them (the auditor will make special mention of the performance of the fiduciary management of the projects);
• The allocation of resources to activities, expense categories and components is respected, and any deviation is justified.
• The obligations of the projects in terms of periodic financial reporting, internal auditing, external auditing, procurement, planning and budgeting, and the hosting of meetings of the steering committee or the equivalent body are met.
• The allocation of staff salaries to projects is consistent with the information in the timesheets completed monthly by each member of staff, and they are of proper quality.

In compliance with IFAC standards, the auditor shall pay close attention to the following elements:

1. Fraud and bribery: In accordance with the standard ISA 240 (Auditor’s Responsibility to Consider Fraud and Error in an Audit of Financial Statement), the auditor shall identify and assess fraud risks, get, or provide sufficient audit evidence demonstrating the analysis of these risks and properly tackle identified or suspected fraud.
2. Laws and regulations: While designing the audit approach and performing the audit procedures, the auditor should evaluate the Project Coordination Unit’s compliance with laws and regulations that could significantly affect the financial statements as required by the standard ISA 250 (Consideration of laws and regulations in an audit of financial statements).
3. Governance: Communicating with project managers responsible for governing significant auditing items in accordance with the standard ISA 260 (Communicating with Those Charged with Governance).
4. Risks: In view of reducing audit risks to a low level, the auditor will implement appropriate audit procedures in response to the risks of misstatement identified in the assessment, this in accordance with the standard ISA 330 (Auditor’s Responses to Assessed Risks).
   • Management of cash and bank accounts; monthly reconciliation of balance sheets; cash management procedures and their validity in terms of control

The audit shall cover all aspects linked to finance and accounting, including:

• Payroll management, recording, and control
• Recording of funds received from funders, and control of their appropriate use in accordance with terms defined by funders.
• Books of account, vouchers, and other documents
• Budgetary control

And more generally, the adequacy of practices regarding relevant procedure manuals will be checked, as well as the quality of these manuals.

1. EXPECTED RESULT

A complete financial audit report including financial statements, all accompanying notes, and a letter of reference shall be submitted to the Country Director of Farm Radio International.

The report shall be well-structured and include a comprehensive analysis of all aspects of accounting and fiscal management listed above; as well as documented recommendations for consolidating and improving Farm Radio International’s fiscal management.

NB: Reports and/or communications on the auditor’s work shall be approved by FRI’s Audit Committee prior to any external communication, under threat of prosecution.

1. METHODOLOGY

The work shall be done based on documents. The audit shall follow a risk-based approach to assessing the risks faced by Farm Radio International.

1. TIMING

The indicative duration for the completion of each of the above audit assignments is a maximum of fourteen (14) days from the date notified to the audit firm by Farm Radio International for the launch of the relevant assignment.

The selected audit firm will sign a 3-year contract for the audit of the fiscal years, 2023, 2024 and 2025. The continuation of the services for the year 2024 and 2025 is however conditional on the satisfactory completion of the services for the year 2023.

1. Technical Evaluation Criteria

Each proposal will be evaluated and scored against the evaluation criteria and evaluation sub-criteria, which are stated in the table below. Cost/Price proposals are not assigned points, but for overall evaluation purposes of this RFP, technical evaluation factors other than cost/price, when combined, are considered approximately equal to cost/price factors.

1.Holds the requisite knowledge, skills and competencies required to perform its responsibilities with due professional care- ( 30 Points)

2. At least three years of experience in auditing not-for-profit organizations

20 points

3. The firm must be registered in Nigeria and adhere to all legal requirements to operate in Nigeria i.e. registered with the relevant regulating accounting/auditing body in Nigeria ( 20 Points)

4.Staff assignment to the audit exercise and availability of staff to respond to questions within the scope of engagement- ( 10 Points)

5. Demonstrated experience of auditing Non-Governmental Organizations – provide at least two recommendation letters from past audited not-for-

profit clients- ( 10 Points)

6.The firm must have been in operation continuously for the last five (05) years carrying out auditing and accounting duties in Nigeria- (10 Points)

1. EXPERIENCE OF THE FIRM AND COMPOSITION OF THE TEAM

• The consultant must be an independent auditing and accounting firm, usually engaged in auditing, and regularly registered with an Order of Chartered Accountants internationally recognized by IFAC or FIDEF (copy of attestation or certificate of affiliation), with at least 10 years of proven experience in financial and accounting auditing of development projects and acceptable to GAC. This criterion is eliminatory.
• The consultant must have at least a solid experience in financial and accounting audit in general.
• The consultant must have a confirmed experience in the financial audit of the accounts of similar projects funded by donors, especially Global Affairs Canada, GIZ, USAID, UKAID. For this criterion, the amounts of projects audited over the last five years will be considered.

The key staff of the assignment shall include at least:

• A mission manager, who is a Certified accountant, with at least 7 years of experience in financial audit and a good knowledge of fiduciary management procedures and audits of projects/programs funded by Global Affairs Canada or another development partners.
• A chief of mission who has at least a university degree in audit, accounting, and other graduate degrees in management and audit, and with an experience of 5 years at least in financial audit and a good knowledge of fiduciary management procedures and audits of development projects;
• A senior auditor with a university degree in audit/accounting, with a minimum of 5 years of experience in fiduciary management or development project auditing; and
• An expert in procurement with a university degree in public administration, business law or management, with at least 5 years of professional experience, including at least 3 years of experience in the procurement area as expert in procurement for development projects or programs or in an international organization. Experience in auditing procurement for a development project will be an asset.
  • Audit firm and staff must be independent of EAI.
  • The following document are mandatory requirements for all proposal submissions:
    • A copy of Certificate of Registration/Incorporation
    • Valid Tax Compliance Certificate
    • Audited Accounts for the last 3 years
    • Company Profile and detailed CVs of the firm’s Partners
    • ICAN Membership and Certificate of Good standing